“Choose a firm mattress for your weight and the way you sleep, and if back pain is the reason you are shopping, try medium-firm first.”
Firm mattresses and back pain
A firm mattress is not automatically the right choice for a bad back. In a randomised, double-blind trial of 313 adults with chronic low-back pain, published in The Lancet by Kovacs and colleagues in 2003, people given medium-firm mattresses (5.6 on the European Hs scale, which runs from 1 for the firmest to 10 for the softest) did better after 90 days than those given firm ones (2.3), with odds ratios of 2.36 for pain in bed and 2.10 for disability. A 2021 review of 39 studies in the Journal of Orthopaedics and Traumatology concluded that a medium-firm mattress promotes comfort, sleep quality and spinal alignment, and noted that claims made for “orthopaedic” mattresses “are not supported by enough evidence”. Five of the twelve mattresses here carry “Ortho” in their name, so treat “Ortho” as part of the name; it is not a medical standard (our orthopaedic mattress ranking explains what the label should mean).
How firm for your weight and position
Body weight is the strongest reason to buy firm. A heavier body compresses the comfort layers further before the springs take the load, so heavier sleepers need a denser or firmer build. Several picks here are built with heavier sleepers in mind: the REM-Fit 4000 Ortho Elite is rated to 20 stone, the OTTY Extra Firm Hybrid is made for people over 15 stone, and the Silentnight’s firm feel is aimed at a heavier build.
Sleeping position decides the rest. On your back or front, a firm mattress stops the hips sinking below the line of the spine, which is the job it is bought for. Side sleepers generally find firm mattresses uncomfortable around the hips and shoulders.
What makes a mattress firm
Spring count alone says little about firmness. The National Bed Federation’s mattress buying guide explains that the gauge of the wire, the number of coils, the height of each spring and the quantity together set a mattress’s tension, and that pocket spring counts typically run from 600-800 up to 2,500, occasionally 3,000 or 4,000. The REM-Fit reaches 4,000 with two layers of 2,000, while IKEA quotes the Vatneström’s springs as a density of 218 per square metre rather than a total, so the counts in the table below do not compare like for like. The Silentnight, Aspire, Sleepeezee, Hypnos and Sealy are tufted, which the NBF says keeps loose fillings in place, and the Silentnight, Hypnos and Sealy are double-sided, so they need turning as well as rotating. Brand scales do not line up either. OTTY and REM-Fit grade out of 10 with 10 as the firmest, Emma uses 1 to 5, and the European scale in the Lancet trial above runs the other way, with 1 as the firmest, so compare the words and the weight guidance before the numbers. If every firm grade here sounds too hard, our medium-firm mattress ranking covers the band one step softer.
The hybrids at the top of this table come with refund trials, so a wrong guess costs you little, while most of the tufted traditional mattresses offer no refund and several of them need turning.
Refund, exchange or no trial
Firmness is hard to judge in a shop, so the trial terms matter. A refund trial gives you your money back if the mattress is wrong for you, while an exchange only lets you swap it for another model from the same seller. Simba, Emma, REM-Fit, OTTY and TEMPUR take a mattress back for a refund, although TEMPUR’s trial terms ask you to sleep on it for at least 60 of the 100 nights and deduct any collection charge. Silentnight, IKEA and Mattress Online, which sells the Sleepeezee, only exchange. Silentnight’s comfort exchange opens after 28 nights, closes 60 days after delivery and can be used once per purchase. Hypnos, Dunlopillo and Sealy sell through retailers and offer no trial of their own, and Aspire sells direct but offers no trial and takes a mattress back only while it is still sealed.
If you are unsure how firm to go, a refund trial is the safest way to buy, and the 200 nights on the Simba Hybrid Pro give you more than six months to decide.
Firm mattress or firm topper
A firm topper changes how a mattress feels on the surface, but it cannot restore support to a core that has sagged, and on a mattress that already dips a new one is the better buy. If yours is sound but too soft, our firm mattress topper comparison ranks the current toppers.