“For most people we would choose the Emma Original Pro, with zoned pocket springs under a comfortable foam top and a cover you can wash. If you prefer wool or fibre over the springs, the traditional builds further down this page are well worth a look.”
What a pocket sprung mattress is
A pocket sprung mattress has every coil sewn into its own fabric pocket, so each spring compresses on its own. In an open coil (Bonnell) unit, as the National Bed Federation’s buying guide explains, rows of springs are joined top and bottom by a spiral helical wire. The NBF, the trade body for UK bed makers, notes that “the majority of mattresses in the UK have spring interiors” and describes the pocket version like this:
“Pocket springs are small, softer springs that work independently from each other. The springs conform and adjust to body contours and help to eliminate roll-together.”
Better units sit in calico pockets and are hand-nested, the NBF adds. Six of the ten ranked mattresses are traditional builds with fibre, wool or plant fibres over the springs, and spring mattresses with certified organic wool and cotton are in our organic mattress ranking. The two IKEA models put foam and wadding over theirs, and the Emma and Simba are hybrids with deeper foam layers. Mattresses without springs are in our memory foam ranking and foam mattress ranking. Vispring’s handmade mattresses, filled with wool and horsehair over pocket springs, have a ranking of their own in our Vispring mattresses comparison.
Spring count
A spring count means little until you know the size it was counted in and whether it includes micro springs. The same unit gives a bigger number in a king than in a single, and totals such as the 6,500 in the Harrison Spinks Silver or the 4,800 in the Simba Hybrid Pro are mostly small micro springs. IKEA is the only maker here that publishes a density, 249 springs per square metre for the Valevåg and 498 for the two-layer Vågstranda, and the Sleepeezee’s 2,800 is counted in a king. Whether more springs are worth paying for, tier by tier and with prices, is covered in our 1000 pocket sprung mattresses comparison.
Fillings, and what sits over the springs
The layers over the springs shape the feel more than the count does. Wool, cashmere, cotton and fibre keep the build open and springy, while the foam on the IKEA pair and the Emma moves the feel toward a foam mattress. Jay-Be leaves foam out of its whole range, using e-Fibre spun from recycled bottles instead, and our Jay-Be mattress reviews compare its pocket sprung models, and synthetic fillings like these are what our hypoallergenic mattress ranking favours for a dust mite allergy. For a mattress that holds its shape, look for the tufting and hand side-stitching that the NBF links to durability and shape retention.
Medium-firm or firm
Medium-firm is the better default, even for back pain. In a randomised controlled trial of 313 adults with chronic low-back pain published in The Lancet in 2003 (Kovacs et al.), people given a medium-firm mattress had better outcomes after 90 days than those on a firm one, with odds ratios of 2.36 for pain in bed and 2.10 for disability. A 2015 systematic review of 24 trials in Sleep Health (Radwan et al.) rated medium-firm and self-adjusted mattresses best for sleep comfort, quality and spinal alignment. The Dorma and Harrison Spinks models come in a choice of tensions. For a firm feel, the Silentnight 1400 Pocket Ortho is the pick here.
Turning, trial and guarantee
The National Bed Federation puts the wear on a mattress at 20,000 hours over seven years. The Sleepeezee, Soak&Sleep, Silentnight 1400 Ortho and Dorma are two-sided and need flipping as well as rotating. The Harrison Spinks Silver 6500 is turn-free and only needs rotating. Traditional builds are heavy, a Silver 6500 double weighs 52kg according to Now to Bed, so turning a two-sided king takes two people.
Soak&Sleep’s 100 nights start after a 30-night minimum, and Mattress Online’s 100-night exchange on the Sleepeezee needs its protector. Silentnight’s 60-night comfort exchange excludes mattresses used for less than 28 nights, and John Lewis runs a similar 60-night exchange on the John Lewis pocket spring mattresses sold under its own label. The Dorma and Harrison Spinks models come with no trial. Rolled pocket sprung hybrids with money-back trials are in our mattress in a box ranking. The full Harrison Spinks line-up, from the Bronze Ortho to the Diamond, is ranked in our Harrison Spinks mattresses guide.
Regular prices, checked 28 September 2026.